www.heyunfeng.com


Search Forum:

Forum Message

Topic: Re:Re:Do stage theories discuss when/how children learn strategies?
Posted by: Michael Lamport Commons
Date/Time: 2010/7/1 21:32:21

It appears in the discussion of stages that there might be a bit of “talking across paradigms.?The behaviorist perspective obviously sees stages quite differently than does that of developmental epistemology. This difference is to be expected since behaviorism is not an assimilation theory, and it does not differentiate activity into its assimilatory and accommodation aspects.

MLC:?That is simply not true.?In behavioral psychology, assimilation is transfer of training.?Accommodation is a subset of behavioral cusps that produce stage change.

Without analysis of the assimilatory systems, stages based on the logical-mathematical forms of the developing systems presents less validity than having many stages of difficulty levels.

Behaviorism appears to concern itself with successions of behaviors demonstrated to be increasingly difficult by their accumulations and coordination of earlier behaviors which is perfectly OK in the study of procedures but these stages of the steps of increasing difficulty conflict with the idea that activity re-organizes and reconstructs its logical-mathematical forms such that both the assimilations and accommodations are transformed.
Behaviorism conflicts with the idea that activity re-organizes and reconstructs its logical-mathematical forms such that both the assimilation and accommodations are transformed.

MLC:?How can that be??Read Commons & Pekker, 2008.?The tree conditions as stated hundreds of times here are that the higher order actions is defined in terms of the lower order ones, organizes them and in an non arbitrarily way.?In a paper last year, I should how higher stage could not be reduced to lower stage paper.?So how can the higher stage behavior not be transformative??The world does not look the same after stage change.?Remember, the MHC is a mathematical system.?It is just not speculative as to the mind.


Entire Thread

Topic(Point at the topics to see relevant reminders)Date PostedPosted By
Do stage theories discuss when/how children learn strategies?2010/6/27 17:27:31David Moursund
     Re:Do stage theories discuss when/how children learn strategies?2010/6/27 17:28:12Michael Lamport Commons
     Re:Do stage theories discuss when/how children learn strategies?2010/6/28 17:12:58
     Re:Do stage theories discuss when/how children learn strategies?2010/6/28 17:13:40Leslie Smith
     Re:Do stage theories discuss when/how children learn strategies?2010/7/1 21:28:14Richard Meinhard
     Re:Re:Do stage theories discuss when/how children learn strategies?2010/7/1 21:32:21Michael Lamport Commons
               Re:Re:Re:Do stage theories discuss when/how children learn strategies?2010/7/6 20:18:11Richard Meinhard
                    Re:Re:Re:Re:Do stage theories discuss when/how children learn strategies?2010/7/6 20:19:14Michael Lamport Commons
                         Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Do stage theories discuss when/how children learn strategies?2010/7/6 20:20:02joe becker
                              Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Do stage theories discuss when/how children learn strategies?2010/7/6 20:21:49Michael Lamport Commons
                                   Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Do stage theories discuss when/how children learn strategies?2010/7/6 20:24:53Michael Lamport Commons
                    Re:Re:Re:Re:Do stage theories discuss when/how children learn strategies?2010/7/6 20:20:59Michael Lamport Commons
                         Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Do stage theories discuss when/how children learn strategies?2010/7/6 20:25:53Michael Lamport Commons
                              Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Do stage theories discuss when/how children learn strategies?2010/7/11 0:00:09Richard Meinhard
                                   Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Do stage theories discuss when/how children learn strategies?2010/7/11 0:01:24Leslie Smith
                                        Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Do stage theories discuss when/how children learn strategies?2010/7/11 0:02:25Michael Lamport Commons
                                             Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Do stage theories discuss when/how children learn strategies?2010/7/11 0:03:20Michael Lamport Commons
                                        Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Do stage theories discuss when/how children learn strategies?2010/7/11 22:33:28Richard Meinhard
                                             Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Do stage theories discuss when/how children learn strategies?2010/7/11 22:34:33Michael Lamport Commons
                                        Observables of behavior2010/7/26 20:30:59Richard Meinhard
                                             Re:Observables of behavior2010/7/26 20:31:46annou2
                                             Re:Observables of behavior2010/7/26 20:32:34Michael Lamport Commons
                                             Re:Observables of behavior2010/7/26 20:33:38Leslie Smith
                                             Re:Observables of behavior2010/7/26 20:34:25Michael Lamport Commons
                                   Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Do stage theories discuss when/how children learn strategies?2010/7/11 0:06:30
     Re:Do stage theories discuss when/how children learn strategies?2010/7/1 21:33:10Michael Lamport Commons
     Re:Do stage theories discuss when/how children learn strategies?2010/7/11 22:35:16Michael Lamport Commons
          Re:Re:Do stage theories discuss when/how children learn strategies?2010/7/11 22:36:03
     Re:Do stage theories discuss when/how children learn strategies?2010/7/11 22:36:44Leslie Smith
     Re:Do stage theories discuss when/how children learn strategies?2010/7/11 22:37:24Michael Lamport Commons
     Re:Do stage theories discuss when/how children learn strategies?2010/7/11 22:40:55
          Re:Re:Do stage theories discuss when/how children learn strategies?2010/7/11 22:43:27aj malerstein
               Re:Re:Re:Do stage theories discuss when/how children learn strategies?2010/7/11 22:44:44joe becker
                    Re:Re:Re:Re:Do stage theories discuss when/how children learn strategies?2010/7/11 22:45:59Michael Lamport Commons
                         Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Do stage theories discuss when/how children learn strategies?2010/7/11 22:46:53joe becker
                              Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Do stage theories discuss when/how children learn strategies?2010/7/11 22:48:16Leslie Smith
     Re:Do stage theories discuss when/how children learn strategies?2010/7/11 22:42:09Michael Lamport Commons

Forum Home