www.heyunfeng.com


Search Forum:

Forum Message

Topic: Re:Re:Re:Re:Competing frameworks from the Humanities and Social Sciences
Posted by: Leslie Smith
Date/Time: 2011/10/21 8:38:17

Good question, Ann!

My postcard version of Piaget's Equilibration account is this:

Life starts and stops as birth and death, and no doubt each of these can be judged under different criteria [birth/conception, heart/brain dead, etc]. The elements in the process are frameworks [organisation, structure, system] used by a subject [agent, thinker, knower] on the objects [actual, mental, possible] in the world, where the framework changes in each-and-every use, thereby linking action A' with its successor A", whether trivially [new content] or profoundly [new form] - sans fin [with neither beginning nor end] and so, in that respect, each of us is a "runner" in a relay race, sometimes transmitting the 'baton', at other times recasting it [Neurath's boat]. The changes always include reasons, whether consciously detected by the reasoner or not. The principal reasons are necessitating.

ps: I admire your succinct question and apologise for this non-succinct answer. But.....
Piaget, J. (2006). Reason. New Ideas in Psychology, 24, 1-29
Smith, L. (2009). Piaget's developmental epistemology. In U. Müller, J.Carpendale, & L. Smith (eds.). Cambridge companion to Piaget. [pp. 64-93]. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.


Entire Thread

Topic(Point at the topics to see relevant reminders)Date PostedPosted By
Competing frameworks from the Humanities and Social Sciences2011/10/18 22:20:31Richard Meinhard
     Re:Competing frameworks from the Humanities and Social Sciences2011/10/18 22:22:42Michael Lamport Commons
          Re:Re:Competing frameworks from the Humanities and Social Sciences2011/10/18 22:24:11Leslie Smith
               Re:Re:Re:Competing frameworks from the Humanities and Social Sciences2011/10/18 22:25:17Michael Lamport Commons
                    Re:Re:Re:Re:Competing frameworks from the Humanities and Social Sciences2011/10/18 22:30:31Leslie Smith
                         Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Competing frameworks from the Humanities and Social Sciences2011/10/18 22:31:51Michael Lamport Commons
               Re:Re:Re:Competing frameworks from the Humanities and Social Sciences2011/10/18 22:28:59Arne Engström
          Re:Re:Competing frameworks from the Humanities and Social Sciences2011/10/21 8:35:21Leslie Smith
               Re:Re:Re:Competing frameworks from the Humanities and Social Sciences2011/10/21 8:36:25Ann Olivier
     Re:Re:Re:Re:Competing frameworks from the Humanities and Social Sciences2011/10/21 8:38:17Leslie Smith

Forum Home